closer.

100 What Would You Do If Questions for Couples, From Silly to Serious

Lottery wins, zombie outbreaks, a dream job in another city: 100 hypothetical questions for couples in eight rounds, plus a guessing game and a text version.

By Closer9 min read

The short answer

Good what would you do if questions for couples drop your partner into a scenario with no right answer, like "you won $10 million and could tell nobody but me for a year?" or "we woke up as each other?" Then you compare answers. The 100 below run from silly to serious in eight rounds, including one for texting.

What would you do if questions for couples work because nobody can get them wrong. You hand your partner a scenario and watch what their brain does with it. Ask what they'd do with $10 million and you learn how they think about money; ask about a zombie outbreak and you find out who takes the car keys. The 100 questions below come in eight rounds, from silly to serious, with the last one built for couples who are texting from two different cities.

Each one finishes the sentence "What would you do if..."

How to play what would you do if as a couple

Take turns. The asker reads a scenario, then predicts the answer out loud before the other person says a word. The answerer gets a minute to explain, and the asker gets one follow-up, which should almost always be "why?"

The prediction is what makes it a game. A right guess means you know how your partner thinks. A wrong one usually leads somewhere better, because it shows you a part of them you haven't run into yet.

What happensPoints
The asker predicts the answer exactly2 to the asker
The asker gets close (right idea, wrong details)1 to the asker
The answer surprises you both, including the person giving it2 to the answerer
Someone says "I don't know" without tryingMinus 1
You give the same answer to the same question1 each, and a high five

First to 12 picks dessert. A full game runs about 40 minutes, and you won't get through all eight rounds in one sitting, which is fine. Save the deep round for a quieter night.

If a question lands on something real and tender, like a job one of you recently lost or a parent who's sick, skip it. Nobody owes an answer, and the game should never feel like a test.

1. Funny what would you do if questions

Open with these. They're fast, a little absurd and almost impossible to answer with a straight face.

  • you woke up tomorrow as me, with my job, my phone and my group chats?
  • a pigeon followed you home and refused to leave?
  • you had to give a TED talk in one hour, on a topic I picked?
  • our couch started talking, and all it had were complaints?
  • you found out you'd been saying my name slightly wrong this whole time?
  • every song you sang in the shower played on the neighbor's speaker?
  • you got locked inside an IKEA overnight?
  • one food had to be our entire menu for a month, and you got to choose it?
  • I came to dinner with a new, extremely confident mustache?
  • your only way to communicate for a full workday was GIFs?
  • autocorrect started changing my name to "Supreme Leader" in your phone?
  • you became mayor of our town by accident?
  • any animal could be your pet, no rules about space or permits?
  • you won a lifetime supply of something, and it turned out to be mayonnaise?

2. Romantic and flirty what if questions for couples

These work on date night, especially near the end of it when the phones are away.

  • we met for the first time tonight, right here?
  • you had 24 hours and no budget limit to plan my perfect day?
  • I asked you to slow dance in the cereal aisle?
  • you found a box with every note I'd ever written you?
  • you could relive one day of our relationship, word for word?
  • you saw me across the room at a party where you knew nobody else?
  • I planned a surprise trip and only told you to pack for warm weather?
  • a stranger asked you to describe me in three sentences?
  • time froze for an hour and only the two of us could move?
  • our first date had gone badly?
  • you had one evening to write me a love song, and you had to perform it?
  • I texted "come home early" halfway through your workday?
  • you could send a note back in time to us on our first date?

3. Money and luck hypothetical questions

Money is one of the harder subjects for couples to bring up out of nowhere. A hypothetical makes it easier, since nobody's real bank account is on the table.

  • you won $10 million but could only tell me, nobody else, for a full year?
  • someone offered you $100,000 to never eat your favorite food again?
  • you found $500 on the sidewalk with no wallet, no ID and nobody around?
  • you could retire tomorrow with enough to live comfortably?
  • we had $5,000 that had to be spent by Sunday night?
  • you inherited a small bakery in a town you'd never heard of?
  • every job in the world paid exactly the same?
  • I wanted to spend our savings on a year living abroad?
  • we could only buy secondhand for a whole year?
  • you won a free house anywhere in the world, with the catch that we had to live in it for five years?
  • someone paid off every debt we have tomorrow morning?
  • you got a $1,000 gift card to the most boring store you can think of?

4. Zombie, apocalypse and desert island questions

The survival round tells you who would ration the snacks and who would eat them all on day one.

  • a zombie outbreak started on our street tonight?
  • we were the last two people on earth?
  • we got stranded on a desert island with one suitcase between us?
  • the power went out across the whole country for a month?
  • you had to choose three friends for our survival team?
  • we got lost on a hike with half a granola bar and 4% battery?
  • aliens landed and asked you to speak for humanity?
  • an asteroid was coming and we had one week left?
  • we ended up in a horror movie and I was the one who says "I'll go check on that noise"?
  • we had to live off the grid in a cabin for a year?
  • raccoons took over our home, and they seemed organized?
  • you could bring one luxury item to survival camp?

5. Time travel and superpower questions

Pick a few of these for a long drive. They open up big tangents, and you'll learn a lot about what your partner regrets, wishes for and daydreams about.

  • you could go back to any year in history for one day?
  • you could read my mind, but only for ten minutes a day?
  • you got to have coffee with yourself at 15?
  • you could turn invisible for one afternoon?
  • you could see our life 20 years from now, one time only?
  • you woke up fluent in every language?
  • you could teleport, but only to places you'd already been?
  • you could eat one meal from your past again, exactly as it was?
  • you got a superpower, and it was very minor, like always finding parking?
  • you could pause aging for both of us at whatever age you chose?
  • you could change one decision you made before we met?
  • you could get a true answer to any one question?

6. Real-life relationship scenarios

These are less hypothetical than the rest, since most couples will face a version of a few of them. Talking them through on a calm night, with no deadline, is a lot easier than deciding in the moment.

  • I got a dream job offer in a city 1,000 miles away?
  • one of us wanted a dog and the other didn't?
  • your family and mine invited us to two different places for the same holiday?
  • I told you I wanted to quit my job and go back to school?
  • we had a Saturday with zero plans and zero obligations?
  • you noticed I'd been quiet and a little off for a week?
  • we disagreed about where we want to live in five years?
  • you and my best friend didn't get along?
  • you remembered our anniversary on the morning of, with nothing planned?
  • I took up a hobby that needed every Sunday?
  • one of us got sick for a month and the other had to run the house alone?
  • we got a surprise week off work together?
  • we were both starving and there was one slice of pizza left?

If the holiday question starts a real debate, our guide on how to split holidays between families has a few schedules that work. And the sick-for-a-month question tends to bring up who already does what at home, and our explainer on the mental load in relationships is a good place to take that conversation next.

7. Deep hypothetical questions for couples

Slow down here. Let each answer sit for a moment before you respond, and ask a follow-up before you give your own.

  • you knew for certain nobody would ever judge what you chose?
  • you had one year left to live?
  • you could change one thing about the way we argue?
  • you found out I'd been quietly struggling with something for months?
  • you could tell your younger self one thing about love?
  • everyone who's ever loved you could tell you one honest sentence?
  • you lost everything and had to start over somewhere new?
  • you got one more day with someone who's no longer here?
  • we couldn't talk for a week and had to show love some other way?
  • you could redo the hardest year of your life?
  • you found out your purpose was something you'd never tried?
  • you could be known for one thing, forever?

If one of these touches something heavy that's happening right now, set the game aside and talk about it for real. And if you ever feel unsafe with a partner, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is free and confidential at 1-800-799-7233 or thehotline.org.

A question like "you had one year left to live" lands differently once a week than in a 40-minute marathon. The Closer app has a Daily Question, one new question each day that you both answer.

8. What would you do if questions over text

These are short enough to send across a long distance, one at a time, with a rule that the answer has to come with a reason. Send one in the morning and let it run all day.

  • I showed up at your door tonight with no warning?
  • we could only write to each other in handwritten letters for a month?
  • we had one hour on a video call and the Wi-Fi was about to die?
  • you could teleport to me once a week, for two hours?
  • we had ten minutes to plan our next date by text?
  • I fell asleep 20 minutes into the movie we were streaming together?
  • my flight got delayed a full day, on the visit we'd been counting down to?
  • you could mail me one thing, and it had to fit in an envelope?
  • one of us could move to the other's city next month?
  • we lived with a five-hour time difference for a year?
  • you got to plan our first day after we close the distance?
  • you could replay one moment from our last visit?

For more ways to play from two different cities, our list of games for long-distance couples has 30 more.

Which round to play tonight

If tonight is...Start with
A first or second dateFunny (1), then time travel (5)
Date night at homeRomantic (2), then money (3)
A group night with other couplesFunny (1) and the apocalypse round (4)
A long car rideTime travel (5), then deep (7)
A calm Sunday with time to talkReal-life scenarios (6)
Two cities and a phoneOver text (8)

If your answers keep matching, test how far that goes with the How Well Do You Really Know Your Partner? quiz. When you'd rather make a choice than explain one, our would you rather questions for couples hand you two options and make you defend one.

Frequently asked questions

What are some good what would you do if questions?

Good ones have no right answer and a lot of room to explain, such as "What would you do if you won $10 million but could only tell your partner?", "What would you do if a zombie outbreak started on your street?" and "What would you do if you could relive one day?"

What are some hypothetical questions to ask your partner?

Try a mix of light and revealing: what they would do with a free week off together, how they would spend $5,000 by Sunday, which three friends they would pick for a survival team, and what they would tell their 15-year-old self about love.

How do you play the what would you do if game?

One person reads a scenario and predicts their partner's answer out loud. The partner answers and explains, and the asker gets one follow-up question. Score 2 points for an exact prediction, 1 for a close one and 2 to the answerer for a real surprise. First to 12 wins.

What are some deep hypothetical questions for couples?

Deep hypotheticals include "What would you do if you had one year left to live?", "What would you change about the way we argue?" and "What would you do if you could redo the hardest year of your life?" Ask them on a calm night and give each answer time.

Can you play hypothetical questions over text?

Yes. Send one scenario at a time and require a reason with every answer, since the reason is where the conversation starts. Short prompts work best by text, like what you would do if your partner showed up at your door tonight with no warning.

Free quiz · 10 questions · 4 minHow Well Do You Really Know Your Partner?Answer for them, then let them grade you. Loser owes a date night. House rules.Free quiz · 8 questions · 3 minThe Couple Face-Off: Who’s More…?The TikTok classic, quiz-ified. Answer together, point at each other, discover your couple dynamic.

Sources

  1. National Domestic Violence Hotline, The Hotline

Do this every day with Closer.

A daily question, games, date ideas and an island the two of you grow together. Free on iPhone.

Get closer. It's free.

Keep reading