closer.

The Four Horsemen in a Relationship: What They Sound Like and the Antidote to Each

Criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling: what each of the Four Horsemen in a relationship sounds like, its Gottman antidote and how to repair.

By Closer8 min read

The short answer

The Four Horsemen are psychologist John Gottman’s name for four ways of fighting that predict a relationship is in trouble: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. Each has an antidote: a gentle start-up, a habit of appreciation, taking responsibility, and a break of at least 20 minutes to calm down. The Gottman Institute calls contempt the single greatest predictor of divorce.

Every couple fights. The Gottman Institute's position, after decades of watching couples argue in a lab, is that how you handle conflict predicts how the relationship will do. John Gottman named the four most damaging habits after the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse.

Below is what each of the Four Horsemen in a relationship sounds like at a real kitchen table, the antidote the Gottman Institute recommends, and how to repair once one has already galloped through. It's general information and no substitute for a licensed therapist.

What are the Four Horsemen in a relationship?

The Four Horsemen are criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. Gottman and his longtime research partner Robert Levenson began studying couples in the 1970s, videotaping them as they tried to settle a disagreement and following up years later. In a 1992 study of 73 married couples, the couples at higher risk of separating showed more negative emotion, more defensiveness, and more stubbornness and withdrawal than the more stable couples. Gottman described the four patterns for a general audience in his 1994 book Why Marriages Succeed or Fail.

One often leads to the next. The Gottman Institute says criticism, when it becomes pervasive, can lead to contempt, and that stonewalling is usually a response to contempt. Seeing one in your relationship doesn't doom it. A Gottman Institute article on repair says a marriage can survive the Four Horsemen if partners learn to repair well. If you suspect one of them is your habit, the Am I the Toxic One quiz sorts you into one of six patterns, and four of them are horsemen.

HorsemanWhat it sounds likeAntidoteWhat to say instead
Criticism"You never think about anyone but yourself."Gentle start-up"I felt hurt when plans got made without me. Can we decide together next time?"
Contempt"Wow, you made the bed. Alert the media."Build a culture of appreciation"Thanks for handling the car today. I know it ate your lunch break."
Defensiveness"Well, you didn't remind me, so."Take responsibility"You're right, I said I'd do it. I'll call them first thing."
StonewallingSilence, a turned back, a sudden interest in your phoneSelf-soothing during a break"I'm too worked up to listen well. Can we pick this up in 30 minutes?"

To see which way each of you leans in a fight, take the fight style quiz separately and compare results.

Free quiz · 9 questions · 3 minWhat's Your Fight Style?Volcano, turtle, diplomat, or fixer? How you argue says more about your relationship than how you kiss.

What is criticism in a relationship?

Criticism attacks your partner's character instead of naming a specific problem. A complaint says what happened and what you need: "The dishes have been in the sink since Sunday, and it's stressing me out. Can you do them tonight?" Criticism turns it into a verdict on who they are: "You're so lazy. You never do anything around here." The words "always" and "never" are usually the giveaway.

The antidote to criticism

Use a gentle start-up. The Gottman Institute suggests building your opening around two questions: what do I feel, and what do I need? In a 2024 interview with NPR's Life Kit, John Gottman said the way you bring up an issue determines how the conversation goes 96% of the time. A 1999 study from his lab, with 124 newlywed couples, found that the first three minutes of a conflict discussion predicted how their marriages turned out over the next six years.

Try the formula "I feel ___ about ___, and I need ___." For example: "I feel invisible when you're on your laptop all through dinner. I need one meal a day where we both put screens away."

When most of your complaints are about chores and who keeps track of them, our guide to the mental load in relationships shows how to hand over the planning along with the tasks.

What is contempt in a relationship?

Contempt is criticism with a sneer. It's sarcasm, mockery, name-calling, eye-rolling, scoffing, and any line that puts you above your partner. The Gottman Institute calls it "the single greatest predictor of divorce."

Some examples you might recognize:

  • "Wow, a whole load of laundry. Should we throw you a parade?"
  • "Here we go. The expert has spoken."
  • Mimicking the way your partner talks when they're upset.
  • An eye-roll while they're mid-sentence.

The antidote to contempt

The Gottman Institute says contempt grows out of long-simmering negative thoughts about your partner, so its antidote, a culture of appreciation and respect, starts well before the fight. In practice that means saying out loud the good things you notice, often and in small doses. Thank them for the coffee. Tell them the haircut works. Mention, specifically, the thing they handled well at their sister's birthday. One concrete habit: each night for a week, name one thing your partner did that day that you appreciated. If you catch yourself rolling your eyes, take it as your cue to say something kind before the day is out.

What is defensiveness in a relationship?

Defensiveness is self-protection that shifts the blame. It shows up as excuses ("I've been slammed this week"), counterattacks ("Well, you forgot the rent last month") and playing the innocent victim ("I can't do anything right, apparently"). It feels fair in the moment, since you're defending yourself against an attack. The Gottman Institute says defensiveness escalates the conflict unless the other partner backs down or apologizes.

The antidote to defensiveness

Take responsibility, even for part of the problem. Say your partner tells you, "You told me you'd book the restaurant, and now everything's full." Defensive: "You could have booked it yourself." Responsible: "You're right, I said I would and I forgot. Let me find somewhere else tonight." You don't have to accept blame for everything. Owning the piece that's yours lowers the temperature for both of you.

What is stonewalling in a relationship?

Stonewalling is shutting down. The listener goes quiet, looks away, starts doing the dishes very intently, or leaves the room without a word. The Gottman Institute says it usually comes from feeling physiologically flooded: your heart races, adrenaline kicks in, and real listening becomes nearly impossible. Gottman has written that once your heart rate passes 100 beats per minute, you can't take in what your partner is trying to tell you. That figure is approximate.

The antidote to stonewalling

The Gottman Institute's answer is physiological self-soothing. Call a timeout and take a break of at least 20 minutes, which the Institute says is about how long the body needs to calm down. Use the break to do something calming, like a walk, a shower or music. Skip replaying the argument in your head or drafting your rebuttal. In one Gottman study, couples who stopped mid-argument and read magazines for half an hour came back with lower heart rates and a more positive conversation.

What separates a break from stonewalling is that you say you're taking it, and you say when you'll be back: "I need 30 minutes. I'll come find you at 9." Then come back.

What is the 5:1 ratio in relationships?

The 5:1 ratio is Gottman's finding that in stable, happy relationships, partners have at least five positive interactions for every negative one during conflict. The Gottman Institute traces it to Gottman and Levenson's lab studies, in which couples tried to solve a disagreement in 15 minutes while being observed. Positive moments can be small: a joke that lands, a nod, "that's fair," a hand on the knee. The fight style quiz above borrows its types loosely from Gottman's research too.

The ratio is a direction to move in, since keeping a tally mid-argument would wreck the point of it. If your arguments are mostly sarcasm with the occasional apology, the fix is adding warmth, during the fight and on all the ordinary days in between.

Can Gottman really predict divorce with 90% accuracy?

Partly. The Gottman Institute says its researchers could predict which couples would stay together or divorce with "over 90% accuracy." Published numbers from Gottman's lab come close. In a 2000 study of 95 newlywed couples, an interview about the history of each couple's relationship predicted which marriages lasted with 87.4% accuracy at the first follow-up and 81% at the next.

In a 2001 paper in the Journal of Marriage and Family, psychologists Richard Heyman and Amy Smith Slep pointed out that these predictions were tested on the same couples used to build them. When they cross-validated similar prediction equations on separate data, accuracy dropped sharply, and they urged "extreme caution" with studies that skip that step. Gottman and Levenson's 2002 paper on predicting when couples divorce describes its own model as post hoc.

The Four Horsemen remain a well-studied warning sign, and one bad Tuesday-night argument is a single data point.

How do you repair after the Four Horsemen show up?

Make small repairs while the fight is still going, and take the ones your partner offers. Gottman defines a repair attempt as any statement or action, silly or otherwise, that keeps negativity from escalating out of control. A Gottman Institute article on repair says "masters of relationships repair early and often," and that repeated failed repairs are a sign of an unhappy future.

Repairs that tend to work mid-fight:

  • "Okay, that came out meaner than I meant. Can I try again?"
  • "You're right about the money part."
  • "I'm getting defensive. Give me a second."
  • "Can we start over? I'll make tea."
  • A silly face, an inside joke, or a code word that means "truce."

Skip "calm down." The same Gottman article says it never works. Once you've both cooled off, take turns saying what you felt during the fight and what you'd do differently, without debating whose version is accurate.

The Closer app has five-minute micro therapy lessons on exactly this, from how couples argue to how they make up, and you can read one together and try it that night. They're practice between conversations and not a replacement for a therapist.

Are the Four Horsemen the same as abuse?

No. The Four Horsemen are communication habits that can show up in any relationship on a bad day. Abuse is different. The National Domestic Violence Hotline says abuse is not a relationship problem, points to the unequal power at the center of an abusive relationship, and does not encourage couples counseling with an abusive partner. If you're afraid of your partner, or a fight ever turns physical or threatening, contact the Hotline: call 1-800-799-7233, text START to 88788, or chat at thehotline.org. It's free, confidential and open 24/7.

When should you see a couples therapist about the Four Horsemen?

When contempt has become routine, when one of you shuts down in most disagreements, or when your repairs keep failing, a licensed couples therapist can help you see the pattern from the outside. The Gottman Referral Network lists therapists trained in Gottman's method, and the AAMFT's TherapistLocator.net covers marriage and family therapists generally. Our guide to whether couples therapy works covers the research, the cost and how to choose. If you'd like to start at home, the gentle start-up and the 20-minute break are both in our list of couples therapy exercises.

Frequently asked questions

What are Gottman’s Four Horsemen?

The Four Horsemen are John Gottman’s name for four communication patterns that predict trouble in a relationship: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. The Gottman Institute pairs each with an antidote: a gentle start-up, a culture of appreciation, taking responsibility, and calming yourself during a break.

Which of the Four Horsemen is the worst?

Contempt. The Gottman Institute calls it the single greatest predictor of divorce. It includes sarcasm, mockery, eye-rolling and name-calling, anything that treats your partner as beneath you. Its antidote is a steady habit of noticing and saying what you appreciate about your partner.

What is the antidote to stonewalling?

Physiological self-soothing. When you feel flooded, say you need a break and when you will come back, then spend at least 20 minutes doing something calming, like walking or listening to music. The Gottman Institute says the body needs about that long to settle before you can listen again.

Can a relationship recover from the Four Horsemen?

Yes. A Gottman Institute article says a marriage can survive the Four Horsemen if partners learn to repair, meaning they make and accept small moves that stop a fight from escalating. If contempt has become routine or repairs keep failing, a licensed couples therapist can help.

What is the Gottman 5 to 1 ratio?

It is the finding that stable, happy couples have at least five positive interactions for every negative one during conflict. Positive moments can be small, like a nod, a joke or saying “that’s fair.” Use it as a direction to move in during arguments.

What is the difference between a complaint and criticism?

A complaint names a specific problem and what you need, like “The dishes have been there since Sunday. Can you do them tonight?” Criticism attacks the person, like “You’re so lazy.” Words like always and never usually mean a complaint has turned into criticism.

Free quiz · 10 questions · 4 minHow High Is Your Relationship EQ?Reading the room, naming the feeling, repairing the rupture. Test your emotional intelligence in love.

Sources

  1. The Four Horsemen: Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, and Stonewalling, The Gottman Institute
  2. The Four Horsemen: The Antidotes, The Gottman Institute
  3. The Magic Relationship Ratio, According to Science, The Gottman Institute
  4. Physiological Self-Soothing, The Gottman Institute
  5. R is for Repair, The Gottman Institute
  6. Marital processes predictive of later dissolution: behavior, physiology, and health, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (Gottman & Levenson, 1992)
  7. Why Marriages Succeed or Fail (review), Kirkus Reviews (John Gottman with Nan Silver, Simon & Schuster, 1994)
  8. The secret to lasting love might just be knowing how to fight, NPR Life Kit (February 2024)
  9. Predicting divorce among newlyweds from the first three minutes of a marital conflict discussion, Family Process (Carrère & Gottman, 1999)
  10. Predicting marital stability and divorce in newlywed couples, Journal of Family Psychology (Carrère et al., 2000)
  11. The Hazards of Predicting Divorce Without Crossvalidation, Journal of Marriage and Family (Heyman & Smith Slep, 2001)
  12. A two-factor model for predicting when a couple will divorce, Family Process (Gottman & Levenson, 2002)
  13. Should I Go To Couples Therapy With My Abusive Partner?, National Domestic Violence Hotline
  14. Gottman Referral Network, The Gottman Institute
  15. TherapistLocator.net, AAMFT

Do this every day with Closer.

A daily question, games, date ideas and an island the two of you grow together. Free on iPhone.

Get closer. It's free.

Keep reading